I tell you, I have tried a lot of different flavors of E-Juice, but have yet to find one that really tastes like a good analog cigarette. I smoked Salem for years and switched to Generic Menthol when they got too expensive. Then started to roll my own. But that is in the past.
Everyone's taste is different, what I like you may not, and what you like I may not. SO---- what I did was to buy a analog flavor and mixed in a straight menthol flavor 50-50. I can live with it. I have been vaping for about a year now and think it is about time to get away from tobacco flavor. SO it is time to get my fingers wet doing DIY.
Not too wild about the thought of Watermelon, LOL .